1. Author/Setting: Written by Robertson Davies, Fifth Business is set mostly in a town called Deptford in Canada. During World War I Dunny is mostly in England, where he fought.
2. 2. Characters: Dunstable (Dunstan) “Dunny” is an eccentric old man writing a novel length letter to the headmaster of the school he works at as an attempt to validate his existence. He’s obsessed with saints and with his own “fool saint”. Mary Dempster is Dunny’s “fool saint”, the woman who he believed saved him and resurrected his brother. She’s a sweet, kind, and simple woman, not seeming to really be fully aware ever since the snowball. Liesl is important to the plot because she acts very possibly as the devil. Percy Boyd Staunton, later known as simply "Boy", is possibly the star of this story in which Dunny is fifth business. Paul Dempster is Mrs. Dempster's son, and he could be interpreted in many ways. The circumstances of his birth could lead to an interpretation as a Christ figure, but his career as a magician lends him more to being an anti-Christ. He is the other character in this novel that might be the lead that casts Dunny as fifth business.
3. Plot: When dodging a snowball as a kid leads to a series of chain reactions Dunny doesn’t know what to do. His poor neighbor went “simple”, which led to his falling in love with her, which led to his sub-concious need to defend her, which eventually made him go to war. In the war he was nearly killed but was saved by the image he saw of Mrs. Dempster. This is when he becomes obsessed with the idea of saints. While on a quest for saints Dunny stumbles upon a magic act put on by Paul Dempster, the boy whose Birth pushed Mrs. Dempster over the edge. Dunny ends up as Mrs. Dempster’s guardian and puts her in a home so that he can search for saints whenever he so desires. One such trip leads him to Paul again, but this time he also meets the devil. Liesl names Dunny as fifth business, the role he has been playing his whole life without knowing it.
4. 4. Narrative Voice: Fifth Business is written in first person, in the past tense. The narrator is extremely unreliable. Davies uses a lot of biblical imagery, not just with the saints, but even Paul’s birth is a parallel to the birth of Jesus. One symbol we see is the statue of Madonna that Dunny finds before he goes into his coma. This statue draws a connection between Mary Dempster and the Virgin Mary. It also symbolizes the purity of Mrs. Dempster. The tone for the most part is academic, seeing as it is basically a memoir written by a school teacher.
5. 5. Quotes: “Having me in the dining-room was almost the equivalent of having a Raeburn on the walls; I was classy, I was heavily varnished, and I offended nobody.” – Dunny. This shows how Dunny is fifth business. He is much appreciated and the world is better with him in it, but he isn’t, strictly speaking, necessary. “I thought I was in love with Leola, by which I meant that if I could have found her in a quiet corner, and if I had been certain that no one would ever find out, and if I could have summoned up the courage at the right moment, I would have kissed her. But, looking back on it now, I know that I was in love with Mrs. Dempster.” – Dunny. This is the first time that Dunny ever admits to loving Mrs. Dempster, and since the novel is about their relationship, it’s pretty important. This quote is also important because it connects Leola and Mrs. Dempster as the two faces of Madonna.
6. 6. Theme Sentence: Don’t let the stories of others rule your life, you are who you are and that doesn’t need to be defined in any way. Dunny lets the stories of the saints rule his life, even when he fights with Liesl he follows the footsteps of someone before him. When he breaks her nose, it is reminiscent of St. Dunstan pulling the Devil’s nose with tongs. The idea that Dunny is fifth business shows that you shouldn’t try to fit yourself into a predefinded position, because Dunny doesn’t fit perfectly into his role of fifth business and therefore spends his life grappling with it. Even before his position is defined, he struggles with his nature.